Inspector Lansing - Carol Carnac

Carol Carnac is a pen name of Edith Caroline Rivett.She was a prolific mystery writer from 1931 until her death in 1958. As a child she lived in both England and Australia. She is credited with creating fictional detectives Chief Inspector Robert Macdonald, Inspector Ryvet, Chief Inspector Julian Rivers, and Inspector Lansing. Some of the books overlap, featuring more than one of these characters.

Her books follow the style of the Golden Age of Mystery. They are difficult to find, and I'm still trying to determine which 18 feature Inspector Lansing. A few have been re-published as British Classics. Based on the two I have read, I'd love to find more

So far, I've only been able to find these two books, but I give them a very high rating for plot, characters, and locations.

Crossed Skis (1952)
The book begins with a group of young people who have loosely banded together to take a ski holiday to Austria by ferry and train. Sixteen people, most of whom don't really know one another travel to the ski resort.

Meanwhile, Rivers and Lansing are attempting to solve a puzzling murder in London that occurs in a boarding house. The neer-do-well son of the owner seems to be key to the solution. One of the flats caught fire, and the body of the lodger was found thrust into the gas flame so that his face and hands are too disfigured for identification. The police suspect the body is not that of the lodger.

On the ski holiday, strange events begin to happen, and the members of the party suspiciously begin sorting out who they think they can and can't trust.

The book culminates with a dangerous ski chase in a blizzard.

Impact of Evidence (1958)

This is set in the farm country of Wales in the winter. Life is harsh, and the book does a convincing job of portraying that condition. You really can feel the hills and the snow and the horrible flood that cuts the small settlement off from the rest of the country for days.

During that time of isolation, an old man who probably shouldn't be driving is broadsided by another car when he recklessly drives in front of that car. The impacted car is pushed into the river where it is lodged. The driver of the other car, though injured, stumbles down to the closest farm to get help.

When a group of men rally under nearly impossible weather conditions to rescue the old man from the car in the river, he is determined to be dead. The huge surprise is that there is another man dead in the back seat.

The story unwinds methodically with many a suspect and potential motive. In the classic mystery tradition, the guilty party is not revealed until the very end.

Mystery Series- Lord Peter Wimsey

Dorothy L. Sayers (Fair Use)

Dorothy L. Sayers, 1893-1957, is considered one of the top four female mystery writers of the Golden Age of Mysteries (1920s and 1930s). Her primary detective is Lord Peter Wimsey, an English gentleman who likes to solve mysteries as a hobby.

The collection of stories using these characters has been expanded by other authors, including the first case alluded to in Whose Bodyand in Clouds of Witness, which is "The Attenbury Emeralds," written in 2010 but taking place in 1921. This book was approved by Sayres' estate.

A number of the Wimsey tales are short stories, which by design are much simpler than novels. Such stories are so noted below.

Of the Golden Age detectives, Lord Peter is my least favorite. But you may not agree. The books are stuffed with French, Old English, and Latin phrases, obsolete British slang and cultural references, which tax even a well-read person's ability to catch the implications. They are somewhat transitional between Sherlock Holmes success at ferreting out physical clues with logical deductions and more modern mysteries.

One of the strengths of the series is a rather dry poking of fun at British society, but as mentioned, you must understand some of the nuances of that from 100 years ago to appreciate the humor.


Recurring Characters of Note:
Lord Peter Wimsey
Mervyn Bunter, his batman
Duke Gerald Wimsey, his brother
Lake Mary Wimsey, his sister
Charles Parker, his brother-in-law
Harriet Vane, a mystery writer

#1 Whose Body?, 1923
A naked body turns up in the bathtub of a nervous little man who lives on the top floor of an apartment house.

The same day, a Jewish businessman goes missing. However, the businessman is not the person who is dead, and no one can identify the body. There is a superficial resemblance between the two men.

There are a lot of literary and time-sensitive/cultural references in this book. I usually like the flavor this adds, but there are so many that parts of the interplay were beyond me.

#2 Clouds of Witness, 1926
Lord Peter's brother, the Duke of Denver, is accused of murder. Their sister's fiance, Denis Cathcart, is found dead outside the house at 3 in the morning. The Duke had been walking about outside, the sister is outside in her pajamas, and other houseguests hear various goings-on.

Why is there so much activity at that time of night, and in the rain, no less?

Peter manages to find an alibi for the Duke, but everyone declines to use it!

#3 Unnatural Death/ The Dawson Pedigree (US title), 1927

#4 Lord Peter Views the Body, 1928, short story collection

#5 The Unpleasantness at the Bellona Club, 1928

#6 Strong Poison, 1930

#7 The Five Red Herrings, 1931

#8 Have His Carcase, 1932
This is an immensely convoluted story which hinges upon the time of death which is absolutely set at 2 p.m., but it is also proved that absolutely no one was in the vicinity of the body at 2 p.m.

Miss Harriet Vane, whom Wimsey has been trying to persuade to marry him, takes a hiking holiday along the coast. She finds the body of a man who has had his throat cut on a large rock formation on the beach. She is too far away from any telephone or village to report the find before the tide will wash away any evidence. As a mystery writer, she knows some things she should do, and she has a camera with her. She proceeds to record a number of important clues, and takes several identifying items from the body.

It is hours before she manages to report the death. Meanwhile, she meets several people on the road, and passes several cottages, none of which has a telephone.

The police are convinced it was a suicide, even after the body is located, days later, caught in some deadly rocks known as The Grinders. Things become more and more complex. Everyone who seems the least suspicious has alabis from about 11 a.m. to 1 p.m., however, an observer in a fishing boat knows there was no one except Harriet near the dead man from 1:30 till after 2 p.m. How can these discrepancies be reconciled?

The victim was a professional dancer, hired by a resort to dance with ladies who are visiting. But he claims to be an heir to the Romanov throne, and a letter to him in code lends credibility to that idea.

For anyone interested in ciphers and codes, the code of the letter is broken, and the logic of how that is done is described in explicit detail. THe code used is the Playfair code, which was in use during WWI.

I like this book better than some of the others.

#9 Hangman's Holiday, 1933, short story collection

#10 Murder Must Advertise, 1933

#11 The Nine Tailors, 1934

#12 Gaudy Night, 1935

#13 Busman's Honeymoon, 1937

#14 In the Teeth of the Evidence, 1940, short story in the collection of the same name
Lord Peter is visiting his dentist when the man is summoned to examine the teeth of a corpse for identification purposes. Of course, Wimsey envigles his way into the scene. The identification appears to be straightforward.

Absolutely Elsewhere, 1940, short story in the collection In the Teeth of the Evidence
Wimsey's brother-in-law, detective Parker has asked him to help with a crime where all the good suspects were elsewhere at the time. An unpleasant and financially tight-fisted man is found murdered at the dinner table. Phone conversations place the man's nephews miles away. There is a man waiting in the library who might like to kill him. There is the butler and the cook. The solution of this mystery depends upon an understanding of the technology of the time period.

Striding Folly, 1972, short stories collected posthumously

Lord Peter, 1972, short stories collected posthumously

Thrones, Dominations, 1998 published posthumously and completed by Jill Paton Walsh